Originally Posted by
Wilfred Laurier
As for function, we have to define what we want pedals to do. And for most people, we want pedals that feet do not slip off of and that we can comfortably ride on. Clipless pedals are demonstrably better at this because they hold your foot with less degrees of freedom than any other type of pedal, and in the case of modern clipless, allow movement where movement is wanted, without sacrificing the security and stability of the foot on the pedal when riding.
It's important to consider the pros and cons of any decision.
You've listed the pros, now list the cons.
For me:
1. Requirement for two sets of shoes if one stops anywhere home on the commute that requires reasonable dress.
2. Additional cost.
3. Possible adjustment phase.
Also, spare_wheel is on my ignore list as (s)he doesn't provide useful discourse, such as that response with negative/abusive overtones.