Originally Posted by
mconlonx
What has me laughing hysterically in this thread is all the people basing equipment use on worst possible disaster scenario. Breakdowns are an excellent opportunity for getting to know places and people you'd otherwise not, and provide fodder for good stories. I'd not hesitate to chuck the drivetrain above for a Rohloff, but I'm not at all sure it would be substantially better.
Bizzarro ultimate touring setup:
Schlumpf 2sp crank, Sturmey Archer 3sp rear hub w/ 90mm drum brake, Sturmey Archer 90mm front drum brake/dynamo hub...
Its kind of funny, when this thread first started I was thinking about suggesting something like this. But I did not want to start a big debate, and I don't use it myself. I have been looking at the those hubs and sort of daydreaming about it though, even to the point of starting to sell some stuff to fund it.
I ride with vintage SA AW hubs laced into 27s or 700c bikes all the time, and have thought about touring with them. As I agree on the adventure aspect of a breakdown, I have wondered about how easy it would be to locate a bike with an AW in it, and swapping the guts or even just one part if it failed. Even if you could not find a donor hub Harris cyclery sells parts and is just a phone call away. But I like to tinker with AWs, and not everyone enjoys working on the simplest IG hub ever made like I do.
As to the reliability of the more expensive modern hubs, just as a few cited journals and experiences cant be made to speak for all of them in use, I am hoping that a few posters here who seem devoted to them don't speak to the overall personalities of all of the users of these hubs.