I'll throw in my vote for the Trek. I like the C-dale but agree with the rolling ad comment. Also, at least for me, the rear brake caliper being mounted inside the rear triangle and the through frame cable routing were really nice features. Neither would have been an absolute must have point but, put it all together and you wind up with a pretty nice package. I had decided on the Elite but the LBS wound up cutting a deal on the LTD. Maybe you can "negotiate" a bit more with the shop?

Good luck with the choice! Your going to have a very nice bike either way.