My last pair of Shimano shoes were bought in a local Performance store - nice to be able to try on shoes.
Unfortunately, that store has closed. There are other bike shops, of course, but that one had large selection of a lot of stuff. There is another Performance shop in Indy, but it's way the heck on the other side of town. But, there is also an REI store up there, too, with lots of bike and other stuff.