I went for it today. Went to Performance Bike and got a Conti Grand Prix 4000S II. Got it at 25mm, with a 330 TPI should be plenty comfortable. I asked the staff if I don't like it can I return it for something else? They said yes everything at PB has a return policy even used tires. Going to put it on tonight and try it out!
The shop that sells that Roubaix pro tire does not take returns on tires too risky for me to just try.