Originally Posted by
lopek77
I'm a big guy, not necessarily fat at around 275lbs. All I know is to stay away from carbon forks for regular riding...I can't imagine carbon fork for loaded touring bike. I would rather have 1 or 2 lbs heavier bike, but with a strong, dependable fork.
I am still firmly in the camp that carbon is stronger than steel, like for like. I know some custom builders build ultra heavy duty forks, but they are the exception to the rule.
Whether carbon or steel, major manufacturers (as far as I know) need to adhere to ASTM standards:
Bicycle Safety and Bicycle Standards
Obviously the custom boutique bike builders are not.
I think steel can be safer when it fails, it does so less dramatically (based on what I have seen) and can typically be caught before it is a safety hazard.