Ahhh, memories; memories of the same discussions when cars and trucks went to hydraulic brakes vs. mechanical brakes. Actually, not that long ago. Then, when they started putting disc brakes on it was discussion time all over again. People were so shy of them often there were discs only on the front axles. Almost identical negative comments to those in this thread.

Now disc brakes are so ubiquitous it is hard to find a vehicle without them. They are better in every way than old style brakes.

I think in less time than anyone thinks disc brakes will be The Standard on all new bikes except special purpose machines. At the same time maybe, just maybe that will allow the companies to put decent tires on the bikes. Tubeless, well made tires that are at least the equivalent of cheap auto tires, decent brakes that make all strops boring are dreams that should become fact.