Originally Posted by
Sunday Rider
This past Saturday I completed my first substantial ride of 55 miles, which is where I had some concerns with my saddle. Luckily, so far, I haven't encountered any type of chaffing or sores, just soreness from my sit bones. I assumed it was just my butt getting used to the distance (I've also experienced this pain when I ride 25 miles, which I've done 6 times or so).
That's not enough time to get used to it.
My real question is are there saddle/short/fit combinations that truly eliminate all pain in that area?
Yes although the specifics depend on your body and riding position.
More padding and softer padding aren't better whether in shorts or saddle since it compresses your soft tissues once you sink into it. Beyond that you can't generalize.
Some shops have great saddle exchange programs. A few on-line shops let you return shorts after riding in them.