Originally Posted by
Andrew R Stewart
Could you test fit a UN55 in a 110 before spending the big bucks? While Bb spindle length claims are a good starting point sometimes a bit longer or shorter fits better. Andy.
I might could buy one or even the cheaper version since returning would be a pain.
Originally Posted by
catgita
You might consider getting an SKF in 110, it has better bearings and seals, and a 10 year warrantee compared to the Phill's 1 year.
There are 3 things to consider: 1) chain stay clearance, 2) tire clearance, 3) chain line. Also, square taper BB don't always come out centered on the BB shell, so sometimes a small adjustment is needed.
#1 is the most likely problem. Otherwise 2mm isn't very significant and is unlikely to cause a problem.
A good retailer will allow an exchange if you haven't ridden it and it is in a sellable condition.
I might look into the SKF a little more. I haven't heard anything discouraging. Though I cannot order them via the shop I work at.
Returns are a hassle since I am not buying it via retail but the distributors via my bike shop.
Originally Posted by
FBinNY
Phil BBs don't use a flange on the right cup, so they can be floated a few mm's to either side.
Note, you don't need to move them by the difference in spindle length, but only half that or about 1mm or so if you buy either the 108 or 113mm version.
Makes sense.