Originally Posted by 1664

Hello - like many posts you see here, I'm getting back into biking for the first time since childhood. First, this is a great resource for someone such as myself. I've learned a ton from reading through the archives.

- Soon, I will buy a bike (likely a dual spot of fitness hybrid) for myself (6'1) and my girlfriend (6'0). Based on what I've read here, it seems like either a hybrid or dual sport bike will suit us best.
- Riding will be done primarily on sidewalks and pavement, but I live in an area where the sidewalks are often uneven and there can be potholes in the pavement. I'd also like the bike to have the capability for some light trail riding and dirt shoulder riding.
- The bikes will be used as an exercise tool and for leisurely rides. I don't have a lot to spend and would prefer to keep it under $300 each ($600 total) if at all possible though I can probably stretch it to $400/800 if I had to.

Given my price constraints, the most common recommendation seen in these forums is to buy used, generally from Craigslist. While I fully understand why this recommendation is made and the value to be found in used goods (I frequently purchase used musical gear and stereo equipment used), this is often daunting for a novice. I don't feel I have the necessary knowledge of historical models made by manufacturers, I don't know what to look for as far as wear or damage, it can make it more difficult to find appropriate fit and sizing, it is hard to know the market and what is a good/bad deal, etc. Basically, I'm not sure I have enough knowledge at this point to make a smart purchase in the used market.

Therefore, I'm more comfortable buying new. Realistically, my options seem to boil down to the following:

1. Buy a new Nashbar Trekking Bike or Flatbar bike or Bikes Direct bike and have it professionally assembled
2. Buy a new Diamondback Insight, Giant Escape, etc. from an LBS

Option 1 would likely come in around $300-325 after a pro build and tune-up and would to allow for Shimano Altus componentry while option 2 would likely cost closer to $400 and land me with Tourney Components. Though I know neither are coveted, I'm just looking for decent starter bikes we can ride for a few years that will hold up well. I understand it's a $300-400 bike and I'm not looking for anything more than that.

One LBS I visited sized us both onto a 21" frame, so I'm comfortable with that. Unfortunately, the cheapest models they had were Treks that ranged $450+. I hope this hasn't been overly duplicative as I know this question is asked a lot, but I'm really curious what the consensus would be in a situation like this - is it better to buy a brand name with seemingly inferior parts locally, or, to buy an internet bike?

Thanks so much for your help - it is greatly appreciated.