Good news! Since JensonUSA has a nice return policy, I'll be able to return them and start my search for another set of tires.
Is the max pressure actually 95psi? The site for Gatorskins showed 85PSI as the minimum and 102PSI as the max. Just curious. Glad to hear you can return them if you aren't happy with them. To me it sounds like they are simply underinflated.