Originally Posted by Spld cyclist

My goals for this bike are more durability and low-cost than low weight, but probably don't need the heaviest duty headset for how it will be used. I would like it to seal relatively well, but don't mind rebuilding the headset occasionally.

If occasionally is annually for clean, re-lube and bearings if needed, even with your winters I would guess a PIG would last for many many years.

There are several choices in the $20-30 range. I would consider spending a bit more if it comes with a big jump in quality, but I have no idea if there is a meaningful difference.

The recommended Cane 40 is excellent with quality bearings, no annual re-builds required.

I have a Ritchey Logic Comp on a road bike, and it's been perfectly fine through 4,300 miles or so. It takes some sort of cartridge bearings, which might be hard to find or expensive when the time comes