Originally Posted by rootboy

This discussion reminds me of a similar one in the world of the bamboo fly rod makers, if you'll allow me a digression. The comparison is apropos, I think. I don't collect, or use bamboo fly rods much. By I do own a couple made by a man considered perhaps the best ever. Jim Payne. Many argue that the quality of the output of makers since the renaissance in hand made fly rods in the last 30 years is better than ever. Which is probably true.

But there is still something about the classic old rods from the great makers of the "golden era" that makes them more desirable to some folks. Many modern bamboo fly rods are fantastic. But I'd still rather own and use an old classic. Much like the difference between a modern steel frame and one from the masters of the past.