Originally Posted by
Lasue
One is a Specialized Rockhopper that fits great and I've had forever............................................................................................. ..........but she weighs a ton and is a beast. I can barely lift her with weight in the panniers.
Most people who tour can't or wouldn't want to lift their touring bicycle with weight in the panniers. Sounds normal.
If I were you, I'd make the very minimal amount of changes to the Rockhopper and just get out there and tour. You'll get first hand feedback which will translate to more meaningful decisions for yourself about future gear this way.