It all depends on your intended use. Do you want waterproof, easy on and off, and durable? A bag that is easy to access while you are moving? I take my camera out frequently while moving to photograph other riders.

I'm not sure what you heard about the Orlieb bar bags, but my wife and I both use them. There have been almost no problems in the 8 years we have been using them.

If the mounting cables are just snugged, not mashed, the mounts can be loosened, removed, and remounted without a problem. I just recently installed interrupter brakes on my touring bike and there is plenty of clearance.

The only problem I had is one of our mounts was broken when we shipped our bikes home from a tour. But that was not the only thing damaged.

I guess what I 'm saying is, don't discount the Ortlieb bar bags without checking closely.