Originally Posted by
dddd
The testing and quality-control of these parts which assures our safety can't go on for 30 years, except as our final "field testing" at our expense.
Aluminum does have a time-dependent "creep yield" failure mode tendency in tension that steel does not have, so near-infinite life under static tension load depends on an extra measure of designed-in stress reduction (more material) in addition to high levels of processing (i.e. alloying and cold-forging or heat-treatment).
The designers are aware of aluminum's vulnerability to such failure mode, but are designing parts intended to be competitively light.
Such strength/weight performance levels are only realized within a certain time period when parts such as a clamp or a hub flange are subjected to constant tensile stress.
It amazes me that these stem and similar hub-flange failures so often happen when the bike or wheel are sitting unused.
Keep in mind, these are/were bicycles and bike components not Swiss watch movements. The street life expectancy for a bicycle was/is about 10 years or less. Most bike and component technologies are market driven with an "Image is everything" attitude (tempered after the fact by lawyers)...
Bike racing is a business to promote something!
verktyg
Chas.