Originally Posted by
chas58
Good info Paul
I think part of the fat bike appeal is that they are slow at everything, even falling.
I like skinny tire 700c wheels when its not too rutted, because they cut through the snow to the road surface. However, if it is rutted fatter tires (mtb) can handle that type of terrain better.
Thanks, that's what I've found to. Fatbikes are as close to a more stable 3/4 wheel vehicle as you can get on a bike and still ride it through snow (apparently 3/4 wheel bikes are troublesome to try to ride through snow). Skinny tires cut through the snow to the road surface if possible, they're faster and lighter, but don't handle loose snow as well if there's more than several inches of it.
I tried 2" tires a few winters ago by buying a pair, and was very disappointed in them. Seemed like they had all the drawabacks of fat tires (cost, floaty over snow rather than punching through it, heavy and slower) but none of the advantages (not floaty enough to handle more snow, not wide enough to prove more stability when the bike starts to slip). I don't know if there's a niche use for them, but it seemed like the best options were either a 30-40c tire, or jumping up into a full on fatbike.