I am looking at too bikes and trying to get something I will be happy with for awhile, but also not break the bank. One is a used Look 566, model year 2009 w/ Rival group for $900 (retailed new for $2500), which I can get for $750 most likely. It is in excellent shape and was mostly ridden indoors. The other is a new, leftover 2014 Defy Composite 2 w/ Shimano 105 for $1200 (retailed new for $1850) I have looked at so many bikes and been to so many shops that I am beyond confused. I understand that fit and feel is important, so the question I am really asking is which will serve me better based on being new to the sport (I am 50, athletic, have ridden motorcycles and off-road cycles, and have played most sports) and is my best bang for the buck.

I really appreciate your help.

Thanks