Old 10-08-15 | 09:45 AM
  #9  
69chevy
wears long socks
 
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 1,614
Likes: 19
Originally Posted by redfooj
So I already bought and installed a Garmin 520, but i'm still mulling over the option of repurposing a smartphone to use as a bike computer.

The phone in mind is a 4.5" Motorola E with GPS/GLONASS tracking and Bluetooth 4.0 (BTLE). Costs ~100$ new. Pair with HR Strap, high-quality mount (Quadlock), and BTLE Spd/Cad sensors, comes out to roughly same price.

Primary motivation are:
*Use Strava as primary platform, so why go through intermediate channel like Garmin software
*Direct integration of sensors
*More choices of monitoring apps
*Garmin known to be buggy, slow with fixes, etc
*REAL navigation, real usable screen
*No dependency on phone for connectivity
*Have all the Live Segments and etc built in (add cheap prepaid data SIM to phone)

Don't use Garmin Vector, so no need for Garmin's "analytics".
Not as long battery life, but unless its a 10 hour ride with screen constant on is a non-issue.
Not as weatherproof, but easily solved with simple cover, and not planning on riding in a thunderstorm either.

Only thing I see as a con is that going across multiple bikes, I'd like quick detachable non-magnetic Spd/Cad sensor that Garmin has...but thats only available with Ant+ (Although I dont really need CAD, just HR)
Also not entirely sure if BTLE supports multiple concurrent devices

Anything else I'm missing?
I use my phone as my computer. I'm completely satisfied with it, but I don't check my screen very often.

I adapted a battery that fits in my steerer tube for extra long rides, but I don't ever need it.

Having a dedicated garmin would probably be less hassle, but I like my phone being where I can see it since my kids are often with a sitter or with friends when I ride.
69chevy is offline  
Reply