Originally Posted by
rpenmanparker
This chart is pretty definitive and quite conservative relative to what you guys are advocating:
http://s120.photobucket.com/user/old_fool/media/bikeparts/tire-to-rim.png.html
I'm assuming a 4 mm differential between inside and outside width. That's pretty standard. Sheldon Brown admits the chart is a bit conservative, but even if you're willing to fudge one tire size larger, there is no way you should run 25 mm tires on a 25 mm outside (21 mm inside) rim. That is three sizes beyond the recommendation. Do what you want, but a little discretion might be in order.
I was talking about and assuming the OP was talking about inside rim width, not outside. Putting a 23mm tire on a rim with a 25mm inner width...essentially stretching the tire 1mm on each side.
Edit, scratch that. I was talking about exterior.
Yes, here's the Enve chart, that's a much bigger differential than 4mm, also they recommend a 23mm...I run 23 in the front, 25 in the back (until I've used up my 23's anyway.:
QUICK SPECS
FRONT / REAR
Material:Carbon Fiber
Rim Depth:35 / 45
Internal Rim Width:18.5 / 16.5
External Rim Width:26 / 24
ERD:584 / 566
Built Weight:1412.4
Rim Weight:367 / 392
Recommended Tire Size:23mm