Addendum: the web page for the insulated gloves incorrectly describes them. It says they're unlined throughout the page then near the cart at the bottom it lists them as Thinsulate lined.

Bottom line:
The black gloves are unlined, the white gloves are thinsulate lined.
The black gloves are suede, the white are smooth on the outside.

My dream glove would be deerskin and smooth on the outside like the white gloves, but unlined like the black.