Originally Posted by
Goriot
Would prefer SPD- issue really is rain as opposed to cold/snow. Coldest here is 0deg C, if that. Usually around 10C (50F).
You aren't looking for a winter shoe so much as a transitional shoe. The problem is that most winter SPD compatible boots are made for temperatures below 0°C and end up being far too warm for temperatures above that. I would suggest the
45nrth Japanther but I suspect that even they would be hot at 10°C. My Lake MXZ303s are certainly too hot for 10°C and they are similar to the Japanther.
Another suggestion is to use a regular shoe and a neoprene sock. Pearl Izumi used to make the X-Alp in a water resistant shoe but they don't apparently make those any more. I have a pair and have successfully combined them with a pair of
NRS Hydroskin socks for cool but not cold days.
I've also seen suggestions for combining a waterproof sock like the Hydroskins and a pair of cycling sandals. The waterproof sock (with an insulating sock underneath) keeps your feet warm and the sandals let the water flow off. I haven't gone that route...yet...but I may have to in the future.