Originally Posted by
RedRockRider
Biggest problem I can foresee is that the frame might be too small. If a bike fits properly with drop bars, when you convert to flat bar, you end up with the primary hand position several inches closer to the seat; i.e., the default "hoods" position is generally a few inches forward of the front of your stem. With a flat bar, the default hand position in in line with the front of your stem. And this distance is often too far to account for with a longer stem, i.e., going from the 100mm stem that is often on road bikes, to even a 130 or 140mm stem, only closes about 1/2 of the distance difference. And if you have an angled stem to raise the bar position, you get even less forward correction, resulting in a cramped cockpit.
Ask me how I know, lol.....
Discovered this the hard way several years ago building a carbon flat bar road bike with a frame and parts off of ebay. Succeeded in building a sub 19lb. bike with very good components, but I didn't correct for frame size, buying the same size frame I would ride with a drop bar, and the cockpit was hopelessly cramped. I put a monstrosity 140mm stem on it and rode it for awhile, but finally admitted defeat and took it apart, sold the frame, and used the components for future builds.
I've been singing this song for years; completely agree. I have long legs/short torso/long arms for my height, but the general principle you articulate holds, for me at least. That is one of the reasons I don't like straight drop-to-flat bar conversions; prefer purpose-designed flat bar road bikes. One can always size up to get the correct reach on a drop-bar bike, but one ends up with a barn door of a frame -- which I can't stand.