Price is the same on the bike at both shops, as the manufacturer just reduced prices on most all of their bikes and pushed those reduced prices out to all dealers of the brand.

I actually did get to ride the 58cm of the actual bike I was interested in at the shop that's a few hours away from my home, and it felt fine for the 10-or-so min. I rode it. This is the shop that took the photo of me on the bike and supposedly ran it through a fit analysis program (didn't actually see them do this though, so who knows...) and told me I'd need the next size up (60cm). They, however, didn't have anything bigger than the 58cm in stock.

The other shop in my city didn't have any size of this particular bike in stock and did the fit analysis using another manufacturer's road bike setup on a trainer.

Decisions... decisions...