Originally Posted by
pdlamb
Isn't the Adirondacks where the (black) bears have learned how to open all the bear-proof cannisters?
I'd still hang the bag to try to keep rats and mice out of it. They'll cheerfully sneak through the tiny opening at the top of the bag.
There was one bear there that had figured out how to open the BearVault (twist style lid) on a few occasions and was named Yellow-yellow by locals (I think it had a yellow tag or transponder on it). But it was shot by a hunter I think a year or so ago, and no other bear has shown signs of being able to defeat the Bear Vault. I'm on a couple Adirondack hiking forums, and have a BearVault, so I've paid attention to those reports!
The Ursack is not allowed in many areas that require canisters FYI, but I'm sure where allowed they would be fine. I know many folks put their food in an Opsack first then in a Ursack, to better scent proof it.
The canisters are definitely a pain, but almost all my hiking (not biking) is in the eastern high peaks of the Adirondacks so required. At least they make a nice mini table to set things on when you might not have anything else around. Some of the large ones can be effective as a small seat too.
For hanging, check out the PCT method (Pacific Crest Trail). Some youtube videos out there I am sure.
Hanging A Bear Bag?The PCT Method - The Ultimate Hang