Originally Posted by
alan s
So after you plug in all your numbers and analyze the gearing, based on your riding style, what would be the ideal drivetrain, considering also what is available on the market?
Ideal, for my commute, would probably be something like 44-30 with a 12-27 cassette. Sugino makes the crank with a proper road chainline, but it's more expensive than I'm willing to accept.
I started putting together my 1x10 last night. It's going to start with a 39T chainring (because that's what I had on hand) and an 11-36 cassette. If I like it well enough to get a narrow-wide chainring for it I'll probably get a 40T.
The tricky thing about a 1x system on my particular commute is that for 99% of it an 11-25 cassette would be ideal, but for that last 1% I need something around 30 inches. So there are two or three cogs on the 11-36 cassette that I won't use much, meaning I get something like 7-speed gear spacing for most of the ride just to accommodate that one hill. That's probably not too bad though.