Originally Posted by
Road Fan
I don't see the shock value. Campagnolo is design, a knowledge-base ("the Knowledge") and a standard of quality, as well as a cache of precision Italian craftsmen....
Rumors in Techieland are that Apple intends to build a car. Are they planning to build Apple Car Assembly line (imagine a little bomb icon when a part is not installed right!)? No, they are negotiating with auto makers (who have factories and know how to run them) and assemblers (ditto) all over the world asking, will you build my car for me? We can pay you well! They are hiring a fab, like they did for iPhones! Why not Campagnolo?
China is just the current move in industry, world-wide.
It's more of a wake-up than a shock. I get what you're saying about design, but think there's a little more to it than that in this case. Maybe we thought we were getting something where the name meant something substantial about where it came from and who did the work. There is the notion that some things are not commodities - that it actually matters who does the work. Some people have a kind of native care for their work, some are kind of diligent mercenaries, and others are completely indifferent and will screw it up unless they're watched like a hawk.
Most people will return to a repair shop, and not go to just any mechanic not because that shop is any better at merely turning a wrench. Anyone can turn a wrench. Usually we make the decision not based on how well they turn the wrench or how little they charge to do so, but based on the belief that they know what they're doing and actually care.
Likewise, anyone can watch a machine cut or stamp out a part and put it in a box. And if they do the work without screwing it up, what difference does it make? Well, it just seems awfully degrading to make cheap labor the goal, and personally, I don't like realizing that I'm participating in that. If a brand doesn't care who makes their stuff as long as they make it cheaply - if they'd rather pay to ship it around the globe than pay a little more to have it made in some more convenient place - then it's just so much stuff. There's nothing personal about it, so why should we care if it has their personal label on it? Sure, some parts really are commodities, but why should a cog be more important than the person who made it?