Originally Posted by
Wildwood
Catalog correct = low on the list of needs.
Period correct = higher on the list of needs, but still not essential.
Anything that makes it more fun = high on the list.
Yes, well said. But on those rare occasions when someone notices the old bike I'm riding, and asks if it's all original, being able to say "yes it is!" is a lot of fun. About a year ago I did a 300 km brevet on my ca 1960 Allegro, which is very close to original (no tubular tires; a couple other parts switched out with approx. correct replacements; new home-made saddle). The comments I received were not, for the most part, about the bike; they were about the fact that I was riding such an cool old bike, and this seemed to make some people a bit jealous. Several other riders said something to the effect "I still have the bike I raced in college. I've been thinking about riding it again, but it needs new tubular tires...".