Both bikes are pretty much the same or at least you won't be able to tell the difference. That being said, I would recommend trying them out and see how they both fit you. The best bike is the one you're feeling comfortable cycling with and not the one with the best components.

And when I say try them out I mean go outside and do a couple of laps around the shop, try to really feel it. Today I witnessed how a couple was "trying out" a bike inside the bike shop (there was about 10meters of space). Don't be afraid to go and try it - you'll have to ride it more than just a few meters so better be absolutely sure you like it.