I also am 6'2" and was 230.(Now 200) My other bike is a 19" Trek 830. I tried all 3 of the bikes you are looking at and went with the 63cm Trek. I personally found it the most comfortable. Of course, each person is different,etc. I also don't particularly like compact frames and didn't like the salesman who was trying to sell me the Allez. I gave the benefit of the doubt to the LBS I liked best.