Originally Posted by
Gotgolf52
I like to keep my bike for years and avoid headache from buying used, plus new bike come with warranty and support from my local shops. As for feel, I am already in love with the CAAD12 105, I test rode the ALR4 and it was lacking and to be fair it wasn't ALR6 with Ultegra. Hence I am here asking for the forum opinions. Thank you.
Hi Gotgolf52,
Since you plan to keep the bike for a long time, I recommend buying the one with the frame you like the best. You can change/upgrade the drivetrain components, wheels and points of contact in the future if you desire.
Regarding "buying used", it's true that it can take more effort---but I wouldn't call it a "headache" because it offers a way to buy a higher quality bike without spending more. That's how I upgraded all the bikes in my family to full composite carbon frames and forks. I would have paid US$2,500 to $3,000 each for the bikes if I had purchased them new. Instead, I paid well under $1,000 for each and was able to upgrade the wheels right away.
It takes research and patience to buy used but it can be well worth it---it took me over 6 months to find a Specialized Ruby Elite for my wife in the XS size that she requires and she is extremely happy.
Kind regards, RoadLight