Originally Posted by
robert schlatte
Consider the source of the above-quoted material. While I generally respect Grant Peterson's point of view, sometimes he misses the boat. Shoe stiffness makes a difference.
Correct; shoe sole stiffness makes a HUGE difference in comfort over a long ride. A too flexible shoe on the wrong style of pedal means the foot is constantly flexing which leads to "hot foot" or great pain.
I think that the OP is looking for something like the old Bata Biker shoe.
Cheers