I ordered one for my new Novara - Safari. What made me send it back was that all the shavings from the drilled holes ended up trapped inside the hollow tubes of the rack, and rattled and jangled around quite loudly. This was also true for the rear version; so back they both went. I then tried the Jandd Extreme, but it would not fit my wide front end. Next up I tried Mountain Man Sherpa, and that one is working out great so far, and the customer service I've received has been second to none; highly recommended.