I know you love to be a critic, but can you tell me where I made any judgement about this case? All I said that I suspected that these accidents might be more common in Sept, when Freshmen hit urban campuses.

You're the one that linked that general statement to this specific case, not me. If you're read my posts on this thread, I never assigned any blame in the case.

One last point. Regardless of the specific cause of right hook incidents, IMO threads like this one best serve if they're used to educate rather than nitpick. I prefaced my suspicion with the desire to avoid debate, but I guess that some people can't resist. I can't help but wonder about how the constant nitpicking and infighting here on A&S can serve any purpose, other than driving away people who might actually care about either A or S.