Originally Posted by
American Euchre
I don't know if I'd even feel comfortable using the tail light, and wouldn't return it at all if there was any noticeable damage: scratches, missing accessory. I MIGHT feel comfortable returning it if it were lightly used, but in pristine condition.
What do you think is a ethical use of the REI 1 year return policy?
They don't sell it as new. They'll sell it at a discount, used, and their staff gets first crack at it.
I don't think it's unethical to use a policy that they've offered you. I've used their generous return policy several times over more than a decade, when it was appropriate. I've also bought many things from REI because of that return policy. It isn't charity on their part, it's a calculated profit-enhancing decision. Just don't be a jerk about it.