Whichever you decide, I would hope you would get back to us and let us know how you like the brain suspension fork. I'm assuming you are going after the 2017 models. I've been curious on how it works on hybrid bikes.

I agree with ColdCase, you need to go ride! I have a 2015 Crosstrail Sport and I really like the Hydro disc brakes and the Alivio setup. But I find having the granny gear a total waste of space and would have preferred the gearing the current Sport has. I've tested the granny gear twice after buying the bike and never used it since. So depending how and where you will ride, you may not need this. But then again, if you are only going riding occasionally, then you may not need the Sport.

Are you planning on riding gravel trails? How long of rides are you planning for the short term and long term? I'm not so asking for myself as trying to give you suggestions on what you need to ask yourself when looking at the different bikes.

Happy Shopping!