Originally Posted by
alan s
Hopefully we all can agree that everyone here speaks for themselves, and opinions vary, in matters of personal preference.
Exactly.
It all comes down to personal preference so my suggestion is, as it always is, go on short tours to find out what works for you.
I have tried riding with a heavier load, and a really light load, and have settled on something in between.
I have tried riding with 4 panniers, with panniers just in front, and with panniers in the rear, and I now have a setup I like.
I've got the gearing I like and when we tour, it is a style I like.
And I assume that everyone else touring has gone through the same process and has decided on what they like. The OP is now going to have to do the same.