Originally Posted by
mcours2006
1. Fit is going to make a much bigger difference than componentry. The bikes have different geometry. Buy the one that feels more comfortable, and get it sized correctly.
2. The Allez is a proven performer from a big, well-branded company. The Osprey is not. That accounts for most of the price difference. See #1.
Ride the Allez. It's an amazing bike but only you will know if its worth $500 more. I will say it will have tremendous resale value while the Reid not nearly as much.