Originally Posted by
cny-bikeman
...and all of that is justified in the quest to get the aesthetics he desires? The odds of finding a frame that "looks right," is the proper size and style, that has paint in excellent shape (remember, aesthetics is the only criteria he has specifically mentioned), is not bent nor damaged, is compatible with modern fork, BB and wheel specs is miniscule.
Well no, not just for aesthetics reasons. He will be increasing the value of his labor by learning new skills. This will lead to increased confidence in fixing his own bicycles which will save him money down the road.
The first bike I built was a learning experience. I didn't get it perfect, so I sold some things on craigslist and replaced them. Now it's perfect.
I and others are not being "downers" but rather being honest and accurate about the problems with his plan. Incidentally, the OP would need to educate himself before buying the frame.
True.