I just switched to Fiziks with BOA's from Bontrager RL with ratchets. There is a BOA at the top and a velcro strap over the toe box. The BOA system is so much better in pretty much every way. Much easier to tighten to the right fit, and to adjust on the fly. They also seem to better accommodate thick winter socks, etc., but that may be due to the different shoe itself rather than the BOA closure.

FWIW, I have very high arches.