I haven't gotten to ride the Volpe. It seems they're in short supply all around the country right now. I too am very interested in the steel/aluminum question. I feel like steel makes more sense but I'm so drawn to the JTS. I even like the color, which it seems many don't this year.
Basically anything is a step up for me because I'm still riding around on my Mongoose mountain bike and lugging extra weighted forks and suspension all around for no good reason.
Can I ask what your ultimate price was from H+S, since it's the same shop I'd be buying from? Or ballpark price, if I'm being too nosey!
Thanks, again, for the thread. You sound as obsessed as I currently am with this decision! ;-)