These are the pedals I have on my bikes right now, and my preference if I had to force-rank.
- Answer Rove – Huge surface area. Great if you're wearing boots
- VP Vice – Almost as big as the Rove
- VP 001 – Big enough
- Nashbar Verge – Used to be by far the best value out there, but the prices have come way down on the VP pedals. Still 20-30% cheaper if you wait 2 days for a sale
- MKS Sylvan Touring – I like these way less than the larger platform pedals. They don’t really grip at all and my foot slides around which I don’t like. They do look awesome on a classic bike however