If it's a commuter, you would likely want a bike with fenders. Even if you don't ride in the rain, sometimes the streets can be wet for hours after it stops, leaving a dirty stripe down your back.

You might also want to look at bikes that can have a rear rack installed. If you are commuting and need to carry anything, the last place you want it is on your back. The difference moving the weight from you to your bike makes is huge.

To me, none of these look to be good "commuter" options. If you really want to do these two different things, you may wish to consider two different bikes.