Originally Posted by
raymour
I'm a complete beginner looking to get into commuting with a bike. I'm looking for more of a sport hybrid. I'll be riding 3 miles both ways (one decent hill) plus any fitness and enjoyment riding I might want to do which might include dirt trails. I was trying to find an affordable used bike but honestly, I don't even know what I need or should stay away from. I want something that is comfortable and I enjoy using or I know I won't use it. I've been looking at the Fuji Traverse, Crosstown and Absolute (I've pretty much ruled the crosstown out but I did find one for a really good price so I wanted to see if anyone had used one?) I've also been looking at the Giant Escape 3 and Sedona DX. I've ridden the Fuji Traverse (and really enjoyed it) and I'm going to ride some Giants tomorrow. Is there any significant advantages to a Giant vs Fuji vs Trek? Are there any other hybrids worth looking into that do well on trail and pavement? I'm trying to stay as far under $500 as possible which I know is hard but this is my first bike. Sorry I'm so clueless! Any advice would be appreciated!
All the bikes you mentioned are good. You'll find advocates here for each one! Let me make a suggestion to add to your list: the Cannondale Quick CX 4. It does pretty well on pavement, and quite well on dirt/gravel rail trails. A new one will run you around $600 (unless you catch a good sale), but you might find a couple of used ones about that will be more affordable for you.
In any case, try a number of bikes before you decide. Chances are, one will feel more "right" to you than the others.