Originally Posted by
golson
Thank you for the feedback and advice. We should stop looking as it gets more confusing! Now added a Cannondale Quick to the decision process!
The major brands are pretty similar, though as you know, not identical. You might find yourself between sizes in one brand/model, but not another. Once you get past the fit threshold, it comes down to minor things. One bike might have discs, another has a 9 speed drivetrain instead of 8, or even a nicer paint job (don't laugh. If you are a low key person, you may come to hate that hi viz yellow or green paint job. By the same token, if you are a person who likes bright colors, flat black, grey, or silver might be too boring for you) one shop might have a better reputation for after sale service. (don't discount this. having a shop that can make minor adjustments, or even handle warranty issues and get you back on the road quickly is worth more than a lb or two or weight, or a slightly better derailleur).