If skinny riders can sway & bottom-out their Brooks saddles then Clydes beware, heh. Ideally a leather saddle should only break-in with a small sit-bone dimple; some Brooks riders love their squashed & swayed saddles but I don't like paying good $$ for a saddle that will have unpredictable geometry changes. Sprung Brooks are heavy, sometimes squeak, suspension seatpost seems like the better option.