Originally Posted by
Lazyass
He's not asking what kind of bike he should get. He's asking which MTB he should get. I know nothing of either brand.
yes, that is what he is asking.
What people are responding with is wisdom and experience beyond what the OP might have on hand.
If a person asks which of two poisonous substances he should eat, would it be wrong to tell him not to eat either? Even though that is not what he asked?