Originally Posted by
zacster
Ok. While I agree that saddles are pretty much personal, I am just looking for opinions on what is OK, and which to definitely stay away from. And while another C2 may be the best bet, I was looking to try something different. There are so many models and variations on all of them now it is hard to sort them all out. How many different versions of each of the Fiziks are there? Same with Selle Italia.
Selle Italias tend to be fairly flat saddles with shallow tumblehome (i.e. the transition from the top to the sides is gradual), so I'd look at other saddles with those characteristics. For example, from Fizik, Arione rather than Aliante. WTB Silverado and SL8 might be good picks, as maybe would San Marco Aspide Supercomfort Dynamic if you want a cutout. Fabric's Line range seem suited and are well-reviewed.
Lots of options, anyway!