Originally Posted by
robertorolfo
Wasn't sure if I should post this here or in C&V, but here goes...
I recently picked up an older Campagnolo Athena (might be Chorus) sealed bottom bracket as shown in the photos. This particular model has two identical cups with no flange or lip on them. The threads run right to the edge, with nothing stopping them or making them "bottom out" against the frame flange.
When I did a dry run on each side, to make sure the threads were nice and clean, I noticed that I could keep screwing them in until they starting going well beyond the edge of the frame.
So when it came time to do the actual installation, as feared it was problematic to tighten them down, without a hard stop to use as a reference point. When I would tighten the right hand cup, the left hand cup would start to spin, and vice-versa left to right. The BB is Italian, so this meant that one would loosen as the other was tightening.
I have the appropriate Campagnolo splined tool, but only one of the. I was able to generate some torque by holding up the opposite side with needle-nose pliers, but I didn't trust putting 70nm of torque on it with just the pliers on the other side.
Is there some trick I am missing? Do I need to but a second splined nut to hold the opposite side in place while I torque one side to spec? Can someone with some experience on this offer some advice?
(For the record: I'm putting anti-seize on the threads, although I don't see how thread-locker would really solve this problem with that much torque)
This flangeless BB allows some chainline adjustment if necessary.
Obviously what's happening is that the BB cartridge is turning with the cups. I would try a little anti-seize on the inside of the cup to reduce the friction. That might be enough to keep the other cup from turning while torquing. If not, then yes, you'll need another tool.
Even though you'll be tempted to use a Shimano lockring tool because gosh, it looks so similar, I'd strongly advise you not to, not with those alloy cups. You will probably regret it. I know I've regretted having to work on lots of BBs like that that someone used the Shimano tool on.