Originally Posted by sngltrackdufus
... don't put to much emphasis on padding when you are checking em out..
the rock hardest saddle might be more comfortable & supportive than a saddle with 4" deep of padding.
Word. The most comfortable saddle I've ever had (and still have) is my Brooks Team Pro S. No padding whatsoever, very hard. Comfy right out of the box. Supports my sit-bones just right without chafing or rubbing anything.
The most uncomfortable saddle I ever had was a padded women's specific model. It had gel inside, and everything sank right down into it, to the plastic shell below. I could barely ride it for a half hour. Ouch!